It’s the most wonderful time of the year — and at Cape Whoopies, Maine’s Gourmet Whoopie Pie, that can only mean one thing: the Christmas Surprise Whoopie Pie Assortment is back for 2025!
This annual fan favorite is our #1 holiday gift, shipping nationwide with FREE 2-Day Shipping in the Continental US. Whether you’re celebrating with family, sending love across the country, or surprising someone who “has everything,” this holiday whoopie pie lineup is guaranteed to make spirits bright.
🎄 A Dozen Reasons to Celebrate (Literally!)
Each Christmas Surprise Assortment includes a festive mix of one dozen (or half dozen) holiday whoopie pies. This year’s 2025 assortment features the perfect blend of seasonal magic and timeless classics:
✨ CHRISTMAS CRUSH
Chocolate cakes filled with creamy peppermint buttercream packed with candy cane chunks. It's winter wonderland perfection in every bite.
✨ EGGNOG
Vanilla cakes with a rich, velvety eggnog cream filling. Smooth, nostalgic, and unbelievably festive.
✨ WICKED LOBY LOVE
Our ruby-red velvet cakes with a silky vanilla cream — as stunning as they are delicious. A quintessential holiday classic.
✨ BROMANCE
Chocolate chip cakes with fluffy vanilla cream. It’s cozy-season comfort food at its finest.
Together, these flavors create a holiday assortment that customers return for year after year — the gift that never ends up re-gifted.
🎁 Why the Christmas Surprise Assortment Is the Best Gift of 2025
1. It’s the ultimate “from Maine” gift
Authentic, handcrafted, small-batch whoopie pies from South Portland — nothing says Maine love like Cape Whoopies.
2. FREE 2-Day Shipping nationwide
We ship fast (and fresh!), so you can check gifting off your list without worrying about delivery delays.
3. Individually wrapped & ready to share
Perfect for parties, office gifts, stockings, gift boxes, and sending to friends, clients, and family.
4. A dessert Santa actually wants
We say forget the cookies and milk. Give Santa what he really wants this year — holiday whoopie pies.
5. A treat that always delivers a smile
Gourmet flavors, premium real-butter ingredients, and our signature Maine charm make every bite unforgettable.
🎅 Make 2025 the Year of Better Holiday Gifting
This Christmas, skip the stress. Skip the guesswork. Skip the shopping mall parking lots.
Choose a gift that’s joyful, delicious, and guaranteed to be a hit with everyone on your nice list.
Order the Christmas Surprise Whoopie Pie Assortment today at capewhoopies.com, or stop by our cozy shop at 185 Cottage Rd., South Portland to pick up a box fresh from our bakery.
Your sweetest holiday season ever starts right here — with Maine’s #1 Christmas gift of 2025.